America has decided to fix its prisons, and it has chosen as its method the most American reform mechanism ever devised: a study tour. Corrections officials from more than twenty states spent this month in Norway and Germany, walking facilities where the windows have glass, the kitchens have knives, and the guards have the same bad coffee everyone else has. The report filed this morning by NPR describes the delegation’s aim plainly: a roadmap for designing prisons that emphasize rehabilitation and a successful return to life on the outside.
I am for it, wholly, and I want to say the quiet part before the tough-on-crime talk radio cycle begins. We have looked at our prisons. We have looked at them for forty years. We have looked at them in budget hearings, in newspaper investigations, in documentaries with ominous music, and in the faces of families at visiting windows. We know exactly what looking at them produces: more looking. What we have not done is look at someone else’s, on someone else’s dime, with a notebook.
The objections are already assembled, and they come in two flavors. The first is the fiscal flavor: you want to give prisoners kitchens? I want to be precise here, because precision is the whole argument. The objection is not to kitchens; it is to kitchens working. A man who cooks dinner, cleans a floor, and answers to neighbors he chose will mostly not torch the neighborhood he chose. That sentence is not sentiment. It is what every neighborhood in human history has operated on, and we have exempted one building from it and called the exemption justice.
The second objection is the sovereignty flavor: we are not Norway. Correct. Norway is not us either, which is why it can afford its model and we can afford ours, and ours, as of the last several audits, is the most expensive per bed and the least successful per person in the developed world. We are, in other words, paying Norway prices for the opposite of Norway results, and the delegation’s actual question was the only audacious one available: where is the line item? The state affiliates running the story carried interviews with sheriffs — sheriffs, not activists — using phrases like “we run our facilities like warehouses and act surprised about what ships out of them.”
A delegation cannot legislate. It can do something older and rarer than legislation: it can put a man in a room he cannot argue with. The wardens who toured Halden-style facilities this month watched a guard named, I am told, something unpronounceable and therefore perfect, plate dinner alongside a person who had been in there nine years. There were no bars in the room. The guard had keys, and chose not to stand near them. Several of the Americans took notes on the keys. This is the whole reform, photographed.
I am not naive about scale. One prison on a Norwegian hillside does not add up to a system. But systems are what happens when twenty-seven people come home with a notebook and one of them becomes a warden, and one of those wardens puts a kitchen in a building that has had only trays since 1968. The kitchen arrives first; the policy follows the appliances. It always has. Every modern American hospital started with somebody bringing back a better bed.
I have read the delegation’s itinerary. It is eight days, twelve facilities, one lecture, and a farm visit, which sounds like a vacation until you remember what a farm visit costs next to a re-offense. America has sent its wardens to see what a country that has almost no crime does with the little it has. They are coming back with a notebook’s worth of ideas for a problem that has never fit in a notebook, and I, for one, will be at the airport with a sign and a notebook of my own.
Reader Comments (8)
These comments were written by our staff. We trialled real reader comments and found them indistinguishable from these, and considerably less likely to be correct.
Posting is open to readers who finished the article. Nobody has ever qualified.
Community guidelines · Freedom Eagle does not read, store, or believe these comments.