For fourteen months I wrote, with the confidence of a man who has never stood in a childcare line, that New Mexico’s free universal childcare would collapse the state before the snowbirds returned. I said it at the fence. I said it at the lodge. I said it, on at least one occasion, to a laminated menu.
The state instead did something worse than collapsing. It ran a program.
Start with the numbers I did not want, because NPR’s year-one report hands them to you like a subpoena. Full-time employment among lower-income mothers is up 23 percent since the program began — measured, peer-reviewed, unforgiving. Roughly half of the state’s 67,000 children five and under are enrolled. The governor says it is going “stunningly well.” I intend to audit that phrase personally, with a lawn chair.
Now the part that broke something in my brain: the money. This program is fed by the Land Grant Permanent Fund, and that fund runs on oil and gas royalties — severance from the derricks, pointed at toddlers by a 2022 ballot measure. I need the record to show what I have concluded: this is not wealth redistribution. This is a royalty check to a toddler. Constitutional law is whatever the derrick says it is, and the derrick said yes.
I will grant one more concession, and it is my favorite fact in the entire story, because it has a conservative spine. The program ships with an actual trigger: when annual inflation crossed three percent, higher-income families — households of four above $198,000 — became subject to a copayment, capped at $148.50 a month, affecting about one in ten families. The program priced the rich, indexed the price to pain, and called it a safeguard. I have never seen Democrats do anything so ruthless and so solvent. It is mean, it works, and I respect it.
So where is the fury? It lives, now, in the queue. A celebrated Santa Fe center holds 130 children and keeps a waitlist near 700. One mother was offered a slot for August 2027. The state set a goal of 12,000 new spots and has filled more than half — which means the other half is real children, in real kitchens, doing real arithmetic. That is the only betrayal the program has actually committed: it worked at the speed of government while the toddlers worked at the speed of toddlers.
Free, but rationed. That’s not socialism’s fault; that’s procurement’s. I have waited twenty years to be right. I have now waited two for a daycare placement, and at least my waiting never got me a coupon.
My waitlist position as of Friday: 431. I have decided to love this state. I have decided not to explain that decision to my readership, my lodge, or the menu.
Reader Comments (7)
These comments were written by our staff. We trialled real reader comments and found them indistinguishable from these, and considerably less likely to be correct.
Posting is open to readers who finished the article. Nobody has ever qualified.
Community guidelines · Freedom Eagle does not read, store, or believe these comments.