MONDAY, 6:02 a.m. — The first thing Justin Tucker did in Kansas City, witnesses report, was kick a football, because the first thing any kicker does when handed a football and a problem is kick a football, and the kick, by all reports, was good. It is always good. That is the entire complication.
By 8:15 a.m., the team’s head coach had been asked about the signing six times, and had answered each one with the same four-part liturgy: the player is a professional; the player served his suspension; the player can help us; with that, time’s yours. The fourth part is not a quote, it is a closing credit, and Kansas City has now watched it roll in front of a microphone for most of a month.
Here is the situation, described with the flat honesty the sport reserves for its own finance reports: the Kansas City Chiefs, after their starting kicker spent the fall missing one field goal in four, signed the most accurate kicker in league history, who is also a man facing civil accusations from sixteen massage therapists across eight states, whom the league suspended and a rival team released, and who has denied every allegation. The signing is football. The questions are everything else, and the questions do not end, they merely rotate, like a defensive line.
By Wednesday, the broadcast booth had joined. During a national game, Jim Nantz raised the signing on air and Juergen Watt turned to the camera with the expression of a man who has been waiting four quarters to say the obvious thing: that half of a head coach’s presser had been spent on a roster move nobody could explain past the word “competition.” A play-by-play voice naming a controversy live is the modern equivalent of a stadium gasp — it cannot be unsaid, and it cannot be rehearsed.
By Friday, the city had done what cities do, which is disaggregate. The bar on the west side of the stadium had a television in every window and an argument at every table. A season-ticket holder named Darlene Futch, who has sat in the same section since the Arrowhead days, put the transaction the way most of them seemed to: she is not for it, she is not against it, she is for the kicking, and she would like everyone to experience what it was like in October, watching a $12,000,000 leg lose to the laws of physics. The league’s own math, posted on its analytics feed the day the signing cleared, rated the move a 0.4-win upgrade across a full season, which is the exact amount of football a forgiveness controversy can be worth if nobody talks about it, and 0.4 wins is not nothing in this town. It is not everything either. It is the price, in wins, of the conversation.
By Sunday, the conversation had arrived at its most American form, which is a bumper sticker that appeared, unattributed, on a truck outside the training facility: THIS IS AMERICA, WE FORGIVE. The truck’s owner declined interview requests by declining them. A second truck appeared by Tuesday with a different sticker, and a third by Thursday with the first sticker crossed out, and the city watched the exchange the way it once watched kick returns: patiently, loudly, and with full knowledge that someone eventually gets hit.
The kickers, meanwhile, kicked. Both of them. Every day, on the same field, in the same light — the old one trying to prove the season was an accident, the new one trying to prove the past is paperwork. The coaches watched film of both. The defense stayed away from the conversation entirely, the way defenses do, which is: entirely.