On Tuesday afternoon, in a windowless room outfitted with the full apparatus of certification, the College Football Playoff selection committee did what notaries have done since the invention of scriveners: it examined the handwriting on a victory and found it wanting. Notre Dame (7-1), widely projected around fourth, was placed at No. 11, behind three two-loss SEC conference champions and roughly every team that remembered to sign on the correct line.

“Signature” is, in this context, a technical term. Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek is its principal inspector.

A patient civil servant of the impossible, the chairman does not judge teams so much as audit the lineage of their wins the way a customs officer checks a stamp. The mathematics are straightforward: a win only counts if the right person already thought it counted, which means the committee must decide, in advance, which wins deserve the weight that would then justify ranking the teams that won them. The recursion is not a flaw in the process. It is the process.

Asked to explain the Irish’s placement, Yurachek delivered the committee’s reasoning in the measured cadence of a man reading statutory language he intends to enforce letter for letter.

"They don't have that signature win right now. They lost their only top-25 matchup. They have a great opportunity this weekend against Miami to get that signature win," chairman Hunter Yurachek

There is a corollary difficulty the committee is quick to note. Because the 12-team field awards automatic berths to conference champions, an independent such as Notre Dame possesses no conference to champion and therefore no championship game to leverage (the committee’s own protocol). The Irish’s entire path rests on believing in a signature that does not yet exist.

Dr. Marcus Bethany, a committee protocol historian retained for decades of study on how rankings are made to appear to have preceded the games that produced them, found the situation moving.

“It is the oldest bureaucratic miracle,” he said. “First you determine the outcome, then you draw the box that makes the outcome inevitable. The committee is not arrogant. It is merely thorough. It is the department of already.”

An IRS accountant who asked to be identified only by his badge number said he had once audited a signature chain with considerably less recursion. When the logic of a win whose validity depends on a committee that meets only after the season is underway required a third pass through the same two columns, the chairman reportedly closed his binder, looked at the ceiling, and smiled, the way a man does when he has finally identified the exact page on which reality refuses to match the form.

At the school itself, junior and unofficial notary-support captain Emma Voss said the team had prepared a response.

“We are mailing the committee a notarized envelope,” she said. “Inside is an also-notarized letter explaining that we played every game we were scheduled to play. If that is insufficient handwriting, we will notarize the handwriting.”

Meanwhile, the head coach of an unranked program, reached at his office, said he had long since solved the certification problem on his own. He declined to give his name, because a signature, he explained, should be a matter of record, but not, he stressed, a record anyone has examined yet.

“We have got our signature already,” he said. “It is on the play sheet. Nobody has stamped it. That is not our department.”

No. 1 Miami (8-0) plays at Notre Dame on Saturday night, a game the committee’s protocol already affords Miami the advantage, in spirit, of having won weeks ago. The kickoff is scheduled for 7:30 p.m. Eastern, pending nothing.