The turkey is cheaper. The dinner is dearer. Both statements are true this season, they were both published within days of each other, and the country has responded with the calm, reasoned debate its grocery industry has always inspired.
Start with the bird, because the bird is the news. A 15-pound frozen turkey is averaging $34.44 nationwide, about $2.30 a pound, which in the current economy makes the bird roughly the cheapest large mammal-shaped food item in the store, assuming we allow the turkey its legal distinction. One national analysis found the full traditional meal for ten fell 17.3 percent from last year’s $166.69 to $137.93 — a genuine, real, actual price drop, the kind economists had begun describing the way archaeologists describe weather: theoretically, in the distant past.
And then the other number: county extension agents, the people who actually price the bags at the fair, clocked the same category of meal basket up about 10 percent, from $68.38 to $75.08. Four studies, two directions, one bird. When asked to explain the contradiction, one analyst — speaking freely, in a break room, over coffee that both studies agreed was up — said the entire dispute fits in one sentence: the turkey is on sale, and everything it travels with is not.
The public has processed the news in the three traditional ways. The disbelievers cannot accept it and say so nightly at their own registers; one Peoria shopper this week described the price-drop study as “cute.” The preppers have never believed a single food price ever printed and act accordingly — one midwestern man, asked whether he’d heard Thanksgiving was cheaper, gestured at a chest freezer he has been filling since summer and said the freezer had “heard things” and “the freezer is not wrong.” And the optimists, the Costco loyalists, have declared the number a personal victory won through card membership and intend to read it aloud at gatherings, per the American custom for any number under $40.
The Study Scoreboard
- Average 15-lb frozen bird: $34.44 — cheapest headline protein of the season
- One national meal-for-ten analysis: down 17.3%, to $137.93
- A county extension meal basket: up about 10%, to $75.08
- Reconciliation, per both studies, secretly in agreement: turkey down, sides up
- Pie: unpriced, legally free, per the testimony of every 15-year-old in the record
The turkey industry, for its part, has accepted the compliment and declined the argument. Growers note that birds this year are plentiful, feed settled, and the holiday math works exactly as it always has: the center of the table costs less than the memory of it, and the cranberry sauce has filed for separate terms. A spokesperson was asked which study the industry endorses and delivered the most honest sentence of the season: “We sell the bird. We do not sell the celery.”
At the Aisle 9 freezer wall in a suburban Kroger on Thursday afternoon, the two numbers stood side by side where they always stand: on the shelf tag, $0.89 a pound in neon, and in the hand of every shopper walking past, a calculator app, a list, and the unshakable American certainty that the store is hiding something about the marshmallows.
Reader Comments (6)
These comments were written by our staff. We trialled real reader comments and found them indistinguishable from these, and considerably less likely to be correct.
Locked at 05:12 UTC after 312 readers posted itemized grocery receipts, one man published a fourteen-page freezer-truck inventory, and two readers discovered they had submitted the same receipt from different accounts, one claiming it was cheaper and one claiming it was dearer.
Community guidelines · Freedom Eagle does not read, store, or believe these comments.