For twenty years, the plan to retire the Electoral College circulated the way an office pool circulates — quietly, with someone always claiming to know a guy who’s in.

Then came last week. Voters in Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin handed Democrats the governorship and both legislative chambers in all five states, and suddenly the office pool has legs. The vehicle is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, under which states pledge their electoral votes to whoever wins the national popular vote — but only once states totaling 270 electoral votes have signed on. Today, 18 states and the District of Columbia have signed, for a pledged total of 222. The plan needs 48 more.

Someone, eventually, has to explain this to the states. And here the plan’s history grows lovely. The compact was devised in 2006 by John Koza, a Nevada scientist who made his fortune as co-inventor of the scratch-off lottery ticket — which is to say the scheme to settle the most contentious count in American history was designed by a man who spent four decades printing a game in which you match three symbols and win a toaster. He understood, apparently, that people will agree to almost anything if you let them rub something first.

The arithmetic going forward: Pennsylvania and Michigan pledge 32 votes between them. Any two of Wisconsin, Arizona or Nevada carry the rest. That closes the gap to 270, at which point the compact switches on and the biggest state in the union stops mattering and becomes, instead, a number in a national tally.

That’s not a conspiracy. It’s an RSVP list.

And the RSVP list is the problem, at least for anyone who finds the plan exciting. To reach 270, the compact needs states that love the Electoral College to sign a document abolishing the Electoral College. It requires, in other words, that a legislature in a state that has never once lost an election it wanted vote itself out of the business.

“I’ve been to two compact meetings,” said Darlene Pruitt, a precinct chair in Holmes County, Mississippi, who has worked elections since 1994 and volunteered none of this history before it was relevant. “Both times it was somebody on television explaining that the plan was not going to happen. I agree with them, eventually.”

Constitutional scholars add a wrinkle they consider decisive and everybody else considers paperwork: the Compact Clause requires Congress to consent to agreements between states. Congress, which learned about ten days ago that it has lost Pennsylvania, is not expected to rush.

The Count, at a Glance

  • 222 electoral votes pledged so far, by 18 states and the District of Columbia
  • 48 more needed; Pennsylvania and Michigan provide 32
  • Any two of Wisconsin, Arizona, Nevada finish the job
  • 270 is the trigger number; below it, the compact does nothing
  • 0 states have left the compact since 2006 — because none has ever wanted to

The folder is still circulating. It has been circulating since 2006, and like every folder that has ever crossed a desk in this country, it is waiting on one thing: the last signature.