BHUBANESWAR, INDIA — The Indian stock market opened for exactly one hour on Sunday evening. Nobody is pretending the hour is about money. This is the most honest trading window in the history of markets, and the world’s investors could learn something from it.
The session is called the muhurat trade — auspicious-moment trading — and it happens once a year, on Diwali, when the stock exchanges open for about 48 to 60 minutes strictly so that ordinary families can buy something symbolic and thereby announce to the universe that they intend to be prosperous. There is no serious position being built. There is no exit strategy. A grandmother buys one share of a company because her son-in-law works near its warehouse. This is not investing. This is a subscription to optimism.
The mechanics, observed in one Bhubaneswar household between 11:07 and 11:59 p.m. local time, went as follows. The laptop was placed beside the shrine because the shrine was having a better year than the laptop. Aunts submitted orders verbally, by name, with pronunciation that the discount broker’s app did not recognize and the aunts did not care about. The family patriarch purchased one share each of three companies, declined a fourth because he finds the chairman “overactive on television,” and closed the account on a note of total satisfaction that no portfolio manager in Mumbai has ever authentically achieved.
Suresh Patel, 46, who handles retail orders at a brokerage on the city’s center’s busy corner, has taken muhurat orders for nineteen years and described the hour as the only part of his job that functions exactly as advertised.
The orders, Mr. Patel says, skew heavily toward a blue chip or two, a sugar company that everyone’s cousin knows, and, in recent years, whatever fund a nephew mentioned at a wedding. The quantities are small. The conviction is enormous. A purchased share on Diwali is not expected to perform; it is expected to witness.
Economists have, with tiresome regularity, tried to measure whether the trade moves markets. It does not, much, in the way their models care about. Roughly one to two minutes of the national volume happens in the hour, most of it retail, and the exchanges have taken to extending the window to an hour precisely because forty-eight minutes of hope tested, on some years, too tight.
What the muhurat trade does measure, at almost zero cost, is how many millions of people want to be formally counted as participants in the economy on the brightest night of their calendar — not to profit from it, not yet, but to stand in the correct relationship to it, the way one stands in the correct relationship to a river.
At 11:59 p.m. the bell rang and the exchange closed until Tuesday. The grandmother had not checked the price of her share on Sunday evening, and did not plan to before her grandson’s wedding. She said she owned it, and that the market now had to live up to it.