COLUMBUS, Ohio — The first rule of the Five Percent Club is that you do not discuss your refinance. The second rule of the Five Percent Club is that the first rule has not been working since June.

Twelve people met Tuesday in a church basement on Neil Avenue to talk about the price of money, which is the kind of meeting America is very good at when the topic hurts and there is coffee. A folding chair sat empty in the circle. It has sat empty for six weeks. It belonged to a man who refinanced in 2021 and has since moved in with his daughter in Dayton, and the group keeps the chair, they explained, as a remembrance.

The reason for the heightened emotion is on the board behind the donuts. On Thursday the 10-year Treasury yield topped 5 percent, printing 5.134 percent, a level American borrowers have spent the better part of two decades being told they would never see again. Markets now price an 89 percent chance of a December rate hike, which would push the Fed’s target range to 4 to 4.25 percent, and Friday brings the Producer Price Index, the monthly report by which Americans learn, in advance and in pencil, what Monday will cost.

The mood in the room was not despair. It was what you might call archival. The members take turns, which is where the meeting earns its keep. One woman described the week her credit union called to congratulate her on her own loan, a rate so low it now technically constitutes an heirloom. A retired postal worker read aloud, for the ninth consecutive week, the amortization schedule of a 3.25 fixed he obtained in April 2021, an experience regulars compared to hearing the Gettysburg Address performed by someone who was there.

Not everyone in the country processes 5 percent as grief. Some of it, frankly, is a correction long overdue, and the group’s own minutes contain a minority view to that effect, entered into the record the way churches enter anything they are not required to discuss. Borrowers who locked low consider the hike a personal insult delivered to a generation that behaved. Borrowers who are still renting consider it the first honest price they have ever been quoted. The chair in the middle of the circle means the argument has a witness, which is more than Congress can say for most of its economic debates.

Even the stock market has found ways to make the number feel personal. The collapse in Nvidia’s shares this week after its chief executive resigned over what the company’s statement graciously called his personal relationships added 5 percent yields to 5 percent heartbreak, and retirement accounts nationwide spent Thursday doing both at once.

The group has a name now, chosen democratically on the model of similar organizations that prefer not to be identified: the Five Percent Club. Dues are one dollar a year. The pin is a small white house with a red line climbing over the roof, and new members are asked, as a condition of joining, to state the year they locked, quietly, to no one in particular.

Linda Ferraro-Moore, who organizes the group and has never refinanced anything in her life, unlocks the basement door at 6:50 each Tuesday. She says the empty chair stays until the man from Dayton can make it back, which everyone in the circle understands is not going to happen, and keeps the chair anyway, which everyone in the circle also understands is the entire point of the club.